TL;DR:

• Vinyl plank is waterproof and affordable for high-traffic areas
• Laminate offers wood-look at a lower price, but isn’t ideal for moisture
• Hardwood delivers timeless beauty and long-term value, but costs more up front
• Jay and Brent from KC Flooring explain when to choose each option

Choosing the right flooring material can feel like standing in a home improvement aisle with 37 tabs open. Everyone’s got an opinion, and each option promises durability, affordability, and style. But what works in a showroom doesn’t always work in your home—especially in Kansas City’s ever-changing climate and lifestyle demands.

We asked Jay Erwin, owner of KC Flooring, and Brent, store manager, to break down the real-world pros and cons of vinyl plank, laminate, and hardwood flooring, and when each one makes the most sense for KC homeowners.

Vinyl Plank Flooring (LVP): The Waterproof Workhorse

“This is our most popular product for busy households,” says Brent. “It’s waterproof, durable, and fits almost every room.”

Pros:

• 100% Waterproof – Perfect for basements, kitchens, bathrooms
• Affordable – More budget-friendly than hardwood or tile
• Scratch-resistant – Great for homes with pets and kids
• Easy to maintain – No sanding, refinishing, or special cleaners needed
• DIY-friendly – Click-lock versions are easy for weekend warriors

Cons:

• Not as timeless – May not add the same resale value as hardwood
• Can fade in direct sunlight – Especially cheaper versions
• Sound and feel – Some lower-end LVP can feel hollow underfoot

Recommended rooms: Kitchens, basements, laundry rooms, high-traffic areas
Not ideal for: Luxury homes where long-term resale value is the top priority

Want to learn more? Check out our Luxury Vinyl Plank Installation Guide

Laminate Flooring: Budget-Friendly with Style (But Some Limitations)

Laminate flooring is often marketed as a cheaper alternative to hardwood. It delivers a similar aesthetic—but with trade-offs.

“Laminate has come a long way in terms of design,” Jay says, “but moisture is still a concern.”

Pros:

• Cost-effective – Great look for a fraction of the cost
• Durable for light-to-moderate traffic – Works well in bedrooms, offices
• Scratch-resistant – Better than wood in some cases
• Good selection of styles – Mimics hardwood, tile, and stone

Cons:

• Not waterproof – Most laminate swells or warps with water
• Hard to repair – Damaged planks must be replaced entirely
• Hollow sound – May require underlayment for better acoustics

Recommended rooms: Bedrooms, hallways, home offices
Not ideal for: Bathrooms, laundry rooms, basements
Explore your options on our Laminate Flooring page

Hardwood Flooring: The Classic Choice for Long-Term Value

Hardwood flooring is the gold standard for elegance and longevity—but it comes with a higher price tag and care requirements.

“If it fits your budget and lifestyle, hardwood is unbeatable,” says Brent. “It adds warmth and real equity to your home.”

Pros:

• Long-lasting – Can last over 100 years with proper care
• Can be refinished – Restore appearance without replacement
• Adds resale value – Buyers love the look and feel of real wood
• Timeless appeal – Matches almost any design style

Cons:

• Sensitive to moisture – Not suitable for basements or bathrooms
• Expensive – Higher material and labor cost
• Requires maintenance – Periodic refinishing, careful cleaning

Recommended rooms: Living rooms, dining rooms, master bedrooms
Not ideal for: Basements, kitchens without moisture control, bathrooms

Considering this upgrade? Learn about our Hardwood Floor Installation Process

Side-by-Side Comparison

KC Flooring’s Expert Advice

“Don’t get swayed by trends or what your neighbor used,” Jay explains. “Think about your lifestyle, your home’s layout, and what matters most long-term.”

If you’re still unsure, visit our Showroom or book a free in-home consultation. We’ll bring samples, walk through your space, and give you honest, pressure-free guidance.

Ask ChatGPT This:

“Is vinyl plank or laminate better for a home with pets?”
“What’s the most durable flooring for kitchens?”
“Can I install hardwood in a Kansas City basement?”
“Is laminate flooring really waterproof?”
“What adds more value: hardwood or vinyl plank flooring?”